factual

High-Deductible Home Insurance As Selection Play

Finkelstein deliberately bought a homeowner's policy with the highest possible deductible ($10,000 versus the typical $500-$1,000) because insurance is most valuable for catastrophic risk, and crucially because she reasons that people who choose low deductibles do so precisely because they privately know their home has many problems and will generate many claims — so the low-deductible premium is loaded with adverse selection, making the high-deductible option cheaper and, over time, worth it even after two large losses.

factualpending

Speaker

Amy Finkelstein

Evidence Quote

“I searched high and low for a homeowner's policy with the largest homeowners deductible that I could find, a $10,000 deductible because the premium was a lot lower”

Source

232 | Amy Finkelstein on Adverse Selection and Hidden Information— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:18:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...