factual

The 'natural level' fallacy ignores human history

The intuition that a species 'naturally' belongs at the level it would reach without humans is a fallacy, because populations without humans are not stable and have no perfect equilibrium, and because such reasoning typically erases the long-standing ecological impact of Native Americans (e.g., burning forests in Yosemite to improve wildlife habitat) while romanticizing only pre-recent human influence.

factualpending

Speaker

Russ Roberts

Evidence Quote

“Neglecting the fact that populations without human beings are not stable. There's not some perfect equilibrium... We're neglecting the impact of Native Americans who changed ecology and habitat in the West”

Source

Terry Anderson on the Environment and Property Rights— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...