factual

Modest versus radical no-self claims

There is a modest claim—that experience leaves open what the subject is and does not reveal that one is a human organism—which is correct, and a more radical claim—that experience positively supports an immaterial Cartesian subject—which is not warranted and does not follow from the modest claim; the radical version is needed to do the work the no-self idea is supposed to do, yet fear of death may not actually depend on it.

factualpending

Speaker

Kieran Setiya

Evidence Quote

“there's a more radical claim which people sometimes make that it's part of the content of experience that i'm not sort of that that there's something in the content of experience that positively supports a kind of cartesian dualism... and i think the modest idea is right but i don't think the stronger idea”

Source

295 - Philosophy And The Good Life— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:54:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...