normative

Peer review's real value is a validation signal

The most defensible function of peer review is not filtering out bad work (people put bad work on the internet anyway) but providing a signal—being in a journal acts as a stamp of approval that helps non-experts and scientists in other fields know where to look for decent ideas; but since peer review's signal value depends on its selecting for good ideas (which Bright disputes), it would be worth investing effort in finding a better way to provide that orientation signal.

normativepending

Speaker

Liam Kofi Bright

Evidence Quote

“being put in a journal is in some sense a stamp of approval. It's a validation of that opinion... there is something valuable about having a means by which non-scientists... can know where to look for the decent ideas.”

Source

95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...