causal

Animals lack a substrate of rationality

Animals like crows can solve the Aesop's-fable water-displacement task by trial and error but fail when hidden U-tubes make cause and effect non-obvious, whereas even young children quickly grasp the causal structure — showing animals cannot interrogate invisible consequences and lack a substrate of rationality.

causalpending

Speaker

Simon Conway Morris

Evidence Quote

“if you make things a little bit more complicated, like for instance, having U-tubes which are concealed beneath the surface of the platform... even a fairly young child will quite quickly learn about cause and effect. The crows, never.”

Source

206 | Simon Conway Morris on Evolution, Convergence, and Theism— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:06:28 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...