causal

Indian Microlending Trial Had Perfect Substitutes

A microlending intervention in part of India showed no effect because later analysts discovered roughly 40 comparable lending programs already in place, making them near-perfect substitutes for the treatment and completely compromising the randomized trial.

causalpending

Speaker

James Heckman

Evidence Quote

“there were 40 other programs, very comparable, already in place. So, literally there were perfect substitutes for what the treatment was.”

Source

James Heckman on Facts, Evidence, and the State of Econometrics— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...