causal

Repeated as-if use breeds belief in the model

After repeatedly using the as-if argument, economists forget it is an as-if and start believing people actually do maximize — the same fallacy as value-at-risk, where a firm not collapsing makes you think you've measured risk accurately — and then leap to policy and social-welfare conclusions based on a model that merely seems to work in some settings.

causalpending

Speaker

Russ Roberts

Evidence Quote

“you then leap to policy conclusions about social welfare because you've claim to have understood how people get pleasure and satisfaction from aspects in life just because your model seems to work in some settings. That's nuts.”

Source

John Kay and Mervyn King on Radical Uncertainty— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...