normative

Judge Trustworthiness by How Experts Frame Alternatives

When experts disagree and you cannot evaluate their reasoning directly, you should judge trustworthiness by how they treat opposing views: whether they understand and fairly represent alternatives rather than strawmanning them, and whether they honestly acknowledge weaknesses in their own position rather than hiding them.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“are they strawmanning the alternatives? Are they saying, well, here are the weaknesses in my view, but here's why it's nevertheless okay, or are they hiding those weaknesses from you”

Source

AMA | March 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:27:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...