It is impossible to distinguish empirically between sadness caused by a life event (death, divorce, job loss) and clinical depression with no exogenous cause. Brain imaging of people sad over a layoff and of people with the same symptoms but no identifiable event shows the same kind of brains.

factualpending

Speaker

Louis Menand

Evidence Quote

“if you look at the brains of people who have been laid off... in the brains of people who can't point to such a life event but have the same symptoms you see the same kind of brains”

Source

Louis Menand on Psychiatry 05/31/2010— EconTalk
Created: 10/29/2026, 7:34:04 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...