normative

Significant planets define the solar system; Pluto and Eris do not

Discovering Eris felt 'fraudulent' as a tenth planet because, unlike Uranus or Neptune whose removal would make the solar system a different place, removing Eris, Pluto, or similar objects leaves the solar system exactly the same—they do not define it in the way real planets do.

normativepending

Speaker

Mike Brown

Evidence Quote

“It really did feel fraudulent to pretend that this was a major part of the solar system.”

Source

11 | Mike Brown on Killing Pluto and Replacing It with Planet 9— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:51 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...