causal

Modified gravity cannot replace dark matter

While the original galactic-rotation discrepancy could in principle have been explained either by unseen matter or by a breakdown of Newtonian gravity (as the anomalous orbit of Mercury was once attributed to dust before relativity), the accumulated evidence from galaxies, clusters, gas clouds, gravitational lensing, and especially the cosmic microwave background is now explained elegantly and quantitatively by a single assumption of gravitating but otherwise non-interacting dark matter (~5–6 times the density of normal matter), whereas no believable modified-gravity theory can account for all these observations—indeed the CMB makes a dark-matter-free explanation essentially impossible.

causalpending

Speaker

Anthony Aguirre

Evidence Quote

“if you try to explain it away with modifying gravity, or come up with a viable theory of gravity that is different and explains all these things, I's extraordinary really difficult to do that, and I think there just isn't anything believable at this point that doesn't also even have dark matter in it.”

Source

51 | Anthony Aguirre on Cosmology, Zen, Entropy, and Information— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...