forecast

Boltzmann brains may make cosmology self-undermining

If a universe with a positive cosmological constant settles into de Sitter space with its nonzero Hawking-Gibbons temperature, then over an infinite future random fluctuations would produce vastly more 'Boltzmann brain' observers (with genuine but fluctuation-generated histories) than ordinary observers, giving reason to worry that the theory is self-undermining — a serious concern, though tempered by uncertainty about what fluctuation means in an Everettian universe and by the dubious use of literal infinities.

forecastpending

Speaker

David Wallace

Evidence Quote

“if the universe is such that it predicts that it's full of beings who have not even fake histories, but entirely true histories that come from fluctuations of their own galaxy to existence or something. I think there's some reason to be worried that the theory's self-undermining.”

Source

158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:31 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...