factual

Cannot Extrapolate Past Assimilation To Today

Because immigrants are people rather than robotic workers, conditions on the ground matter enormously and one cannot assume that immigration outcomes from one place and time will recur elsewhere; the 20th-century melting-pot success rested on now-absent conditions like unionized manufacturing, wartime assimilation pressure, and a pro-assimilation culture, so linear extrapolation into the future is unwarranted.

factualpending

Speaker

George Borjas

Evidence Quote

“A lot of people look at that 20th century experience and say... 'it all worked out in the 20th century and therefore you can just extrapolate into the future, and it will work out fine.' And this is one of the points I want to make in the book... You cannot use things that happen at one place at one time, regarding immigration, and imagine that it will happen in another place at another time.”

Source

George Borjas on Immigration and We Wanted Workers— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:41 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...