factual
Peer Review Fails Through Appeals to Authority
Peer review fails when journals reject valid challenges from credentialed scholars on the grounds that a giant of the field could not possibly have made such a mistake—an illegitimate a priori appeal to authority rather than evidence.
factualpending
Speaker
Tom NicholsEvidence Quote
“it is a priori impossible that he could have made that kind of mistake uh and i think that's where peer review fails”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:06:40 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...