causal

Presumptuous Philosopher Refutes Self-Indication

The self-indication assumption implies the absurd 'presumptuous philosopher' result: faced with two finite-universe hypotheses differing only in observer count (e.g. trillion-trillion vs trillion-trillion-trillion observers), one could declare the larger-population hypothesis a trillion times more likely without running any experiment, purely from the fact of one's own existence—an overreach that counts as evidence against the self-indication assumption.

causalpending

Speaker

Nick Bostrom

Evidence Quote

“the objection is that we don't really accept that. It just seems crazy... here instead, you're ruling out hypotheses, where there are slightly fewer, but still a huge number of people in the universe, just by considering the fact that you exist. It also seems a little bit like an overreach.”

Source

111 | Nick Bostrom on Anthropic Selection and Living in a Simulation— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:21:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...