Three borders of defeat define the modern great power system: Taiwan (China's strategic vulnerability forcing revisionism), Ukraine (Russia's vulnerability forcing revisionism), and Israel's borders (Iran and Arab neighbors' vulnerability forcing revisionism); these cannot be negotiated or subject to détente because they represent existential grievances, unlike the Soviet borders which were borders of victory and thus stabilizable.

definitionpending

Speaker

Stephen Kotkin

Evidence Quote

“You have three borders of defeat in the world today...That's not something you negotiate. That's not something you reach detente on.”

Source

Niall Ferguson, Victor Davis Hanson and Stephen Kotkin: Three Historians Debate The Era of Trump— Hoover Institution
Created: 8/11/2026, 7:30:05 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...