factual

Independent State Legislature Theory Danger

Trump Republicans promote the 'independent state legislature' theory — that Article II makes a state legislature the ultimate authority over choosing electors no matter what — used in 2020 to try to persuade Republican-controlled legislatures in seven states Biden won to discard the popular vote and substitute Trump electors; while it's almost certainly not valid to overturn an already-held election, legislatures can write the pre-election rules, and voting-law experts are pessimistic Congress can prevent state-level subversion.

factualpending

Speaker

Barton Gellman

Evidence Quote

“in this extremely muscular and implausible reading of the constitution article 2 says that the legislature decides on the electors no matter what”

Source

274 - The Future Of American Democracy— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:56:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...