causal

Causal Exclusion Arguments Prove Too Much

Causal-closure or causal-exclusion arguments risk excluding too much: if everything is ultimately explained by fermions and bosons, then beliefs and desires also lose explanatory room unless they are nothing but arrangements of fundamental particles—a view few in philosophy of mind hold—so jettisoning moral features on these grounds may force jettisoning much one is unwilling to give up.

causalpending

Speaker

Russ Shafer-Landau

Evidence Quote

“they're going to, in the end, exclude too much if we think that everything can ultimately be explained... then that leaves little room for beliefs and desires, for instance, do in explaining, unless you think that a belief is nothing other than an arrangement of fermions and bosons”

Source

107 | Russ Shafer-Landau on the Reality of Morality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...