factual

Classic papers fail re-review when anonymized

An illustrative experiment in which classic, highly-cited papers were anonymized with non-essential identifying details lightly changed and resubmitted for review found about half were rejected on grounds of serious technical flaws; relatedly, super highly-cited papers tend to be more daring, and boring-but-true papers are easier to publish than interesting-and-daring ones, indicating a conservative bias in review.

factualpending

Speaker

Liam Kofi Bright

Evidence Quote

“people anonymized and lightly changed non-essential identifying details of classic papers, incredibly highly cited, resubmitted them for review, and I think it was like half were rejected on grounds of serious technical flaws.”

Source

95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...