factual

Foundations Not Required for Mathematical Insight

A robust rigorous foundation is apparently not required to make enduring mathematical insights, as shown by Newton and Leibniz proving all the fundamental theorems of calculus using infinitesimals that were not rigorously founded until non-standard analysis in the 1950s; thus the choice of philosophical foundation does not directly drive mathematical progress.

factualpending

Speaker

Joel David Hamkins

Evidence Quote

“do you need a robust, rigorous foundation of mathematics to make enduring insights in mathematics? And the answer, regrettably, is apparently not because in calculus, even with that lousy, creaky foundation of infinitesimals not even well understood that Newton and Leibniz had, they proved all the fundamental theorems of calculus”

Source

Joel David Hamkins— Lex Fridman Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:33:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...