factual

Past Hypothesis Cannot Be Ruled Out By Data

You cannot use experiment to rule out a fluctuating universe and prove the past hypothesis, because Bayesian theory choice requires multiplying the likelihood by the prior; in a randomly fluctuating universe the prior probability that current ordered observations just fluctuated into existence is so overwhelmingly large that no amount of new likelihood data can beat it down, so the past hypothesis must be assumed rather than derived.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“To choose between the theories, you have to multiply that likelihood function by the prior.”

Source

AMA | December 2022— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:12:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...