The disagreement between aid optimists and skeptics stems largely from a philosophical divide dating to the 18th-century Enlightenment: a top-down view that places experts and leaders at the center of history and treats society as malleable to expert-designed interventions (utopian social engineering, à la the French Revolution, Sachs, Collier), versus an evolutionary, gradualist Burkean view that institutions evolve, experts lack the knowledge to remake society, and only humble incremental change works.

factualpending

Speaker

William Easterly

Evidence Quote

“call yours and people like... Jeffrey Sachs of course also are very much in this first camp of kind of what Karl Popper called utopian social engineering... and I'm... in the camp... of the evolutionary gradual kind of thinker”

Source

William Easterly on Growth, Poverty, and Aid 02/11/2008— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:01:32 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...