The IAU's two criteria for planethood (rounding itself by gravity, and clearing the space around it) have no intrinsic scientific interest; they were adopted by majority vote in order to retrieve a target set of planets, ending up with eight rather than the desired nine.

causalpending

Speaker

David Weinberger

Evidence Quote

“they they came up those two rules simply in order to get the nine back there is nothing scientifically interesting about either of those properties”

Source

David Weinberger on Everything is Miscellaneous & Wonderful World of Digital Information 6/18/2007— EconTalk
Created: 6/16/2026, 3:03:21 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...