causal

SIA Forces Presumptuous Cosmological Conclusions

Accepting the thirder/SIA view—that worlds with many instantiations of your state of mind get a boost—forces the conclusion that a cosmological theory positing many observers gets a large evidential boost merely because there are more copies of you, a presumptuous result that lets cosmological determinations depend on this factor from the armchair.

causalpending

Speaker

Adam Elga

Evidence Quote

“Someone who is attracted to the thirder type view... is committed to saying that theory B in this case gets a big boost. And there they are, sitting in their philosopher's chair, and how presumptuous.”

Source

345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:14 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...