causal

Oxygen's effect on size is non-monotonic

Contrary to the long-held assumption of a monotonic relationship where more oxygen yields larger organisms, evolution experiments with snowflake yeast show a 'Nike swoosh' pattern: yeast evolve large size with no oxygen (fermenters) and with abundant oxygen, but stay small under limiting oxygen, because a small amount of oxygen is a valuable resource that creates a selective incentive to stay small so a larger proportion of cells can access it.

causalpending

Speaker

William Ratcliff

Evidence Quote

“They get really big when they have no oxygen, they evolve to be really big when they have lots of oxygen, and when oxygen is limiting, they actually stayed small”

Source

175 | William Ratcliff on Multicellularity, Physics, and Evolution— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...