normative

Skepticism of one's beliefs cannot be applied indiscriminately

It is easy to say one should be critical of one's own beliefs but hard to know which beliefs to doubt; the argument 'you admit you're sometimes wrong, therefore you should doubt this belief now' is logically invalid, since one can be sometimes wrong in general yet highly confident in a particular case. The aspiration is to be a good Bayesian assigning credences proportional to the reasons for them.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“When you say something that is true and your opponent says, well, do you think you're always right?... And they say, well, okay, you should be doubtful of it this time. That doesn't follow logically, like maybe this particular time, you're pretty darn confident.”

Source

AMA | May 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...