factual

Theory-experiment discrepancy was inexplicable in principle

When physicists calculated the order parameter near a continuous phase transition, the answer disagreed completely with experiment, and crucially nothing in the model's description could account for the discrepancy even in principle—it was not a matter of tweaking a parameter—which signaled that a fundamental assumption was wrong.

factualpending

Speaker

Nigel Goldenfeld

Evidence Quote

“there is nothing you can think of in your description that is responsible for this discrepancy... It's like you can't even understand in principle how this discrepancy can occur.”

Source

163 | Nigel Goldenfeld on Phase Transitions, Criticality, and Biology— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:50 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...