factual

Smolin's Cosmic Natural Selection Likely Falsified

Lee Smolin's cosmological natural selection — universes born at black hole centers inheriting slightly different physics, selected for reproductive success — never caught on because the mechanism for making new universes inside black holes and varying their laws was never specified (standard physics expects a singularity, not a new universe), and because the theory would naively optimize for making black holes, yet our universe has far fewer black holes than stars or planets and one can easily imagine laws making black holes more easily, so the data seem to argue against it.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“our universe is nowhere close to optimizing the number of black holes that it could make... So if anything, the data seem to be against this particular idea.”

Source

AMA | October 2022— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...