normative

Extraordinary Claims Should Appear in Top Venues

When evaluating a shocking or extraordinary scientific claim outside your expertise, look at the venues in which it appears and the credence given by well-regarded experts: genuinely world-changing ideas may not come from prominent people, but they will be relatively quickly embraced by a reasonable fraction of serious scholars; if no one credible jumps on it, that itself is informative.

normativepending

Speaker

Carl Bergstrom

Evidence Quote

“if somebody makes a really shocking or extraordinary claim, you want to look at the venues in which that claim appears, and the credence that it's given by people who are well thought of in the field”

Source

108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...