definition

Atlantis analogy for compatibilism's evasion

Compatibilism is like saying Atlantis exists because Sicily exists: people are infatuated with a mythical underwater kingdom with advanced technology, and compatibilism points to a real geographical antecedent (Sicily) that conserves much of what people care about, but the underwater-kingdom feature people are actually attached to remains fiction; by purifying free will, compatibilism stops interacting with the subjective piece that motivates the whole discussion.

definitionpending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“the whole reason why we're talking about atlantis in the first place is with this other piece that people are attached to which by you purifying the subject you're actually just no longer interacting with that subjective piece”

Source

39 - Free Will Revisited— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:25:04 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...