normative
History Is a Discipline, Folklore Is Not
Civic myth and national folklore have a real place in a culture, but history is an academic discipline with rules, standards of evidence, and criteria for argument; it is a mistake to accept a lesser, feel-good version of the past simply because it suits us—just as it would be wrong to accept alchemy in place of chemistry or astrology in place of astronomy—and the confusion is compounded because we call both folklore and rigorous scholarship by the same name, 'history.'
normativepending
Speaker
Jill LeporeEvidence Quote
“it's weird that we accept that there is a lesser version of a careful, cautious, honest, evidence-based historical scholarship that we should just put up with because it sort of suits us”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:18:22 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...