causal
Truth theories can recover each other's virtues
Each theory of truth picks up on something real (goal-fulfillment for pragmatism, self-consistency for coherentism), and rival theories can recover those virtues within their own framework—e.g., a correspondence theorist holds that the facts can't be mutually inconsistent, so an incoherent (inconsistent) theory must be false. Because any theory can recover the nice things you want to say, this suggests truth itself isn't doing much work, which tempts people toward deflationism.
causalpending
Speaker
Liam Kofi BrightEvidence Quote
“you can recover whatever nice things you wanna say about one theory of truth within the other theory of truth. And without just being a justification for deflationism, it can prompt the thought that truth... It doesn't really matter what you end up saying about truth.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:43 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...