causal

Coincidences reflect shared social background not genes

The dramatic 'Jim twins' coincidences (both named Jim, both married Lindas then Bettys, both had adopted brothers named Larry, both had dogs named Toy) cannot be genetic—genes cannot telepathically influence adoptive parents' choices—and instead reveal that the twins were placed into similar conformist suburban Ohio families, so the apparent natural experiment actually captured a shared social background, not genetic determinism.

causalpending

Speaker

David Bessis

Evidence Quote

“it just means that the two of them were placed into distant families, both in suburban Ohio, and probably people who adopt kids. They're not random people... your natural experiment is just something about the social background of suburban Ohio in the 1940s”

Source

Nature, Nurture, and Identical Twins (with David Bessis)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:27 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...