normative

Maximin Favors Neutralizing Over Killing Threats

For security and military robots, contractarianism via maximin would favor neutralizing a threat over killing the threatening agent, because killing makes that agent maximally worse off while neutralization is the best of possible outcomes; an ideal war robot ordered to kill could refuse and instead apprehend, analogous to military ethics rules against obeying orders to commit war crimes.

normativepending

Speaker

Derek Leben

Evidence Quote

“the ideal autonomous robot in war would be commanded to kill an enemy soldier, and the robot would say, "No thank you, but I am going to apprehend him and take him into prison."”

Source

30 | Derek Leben on Ethics for Robots and Artificial Intelligences— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...