causal

Biased Production, Objective Evaluation of Reasons

Reason has two asymmetric sides: when producing arguments to convince others we are thoroughly biased toward our own view (confirmation/myside bias makes evolutionary sense for persuasion), but when evaluating others' arguments our incentives shift toward accuracy, so we judge arguments fairly—accepting good ones even when they challenge us and rejecting bad ones; the back-and-forth between biased production and objective evaluation is what makes group reasoning work.

causalpending

Speaker

Hugo Mercier

Evidence Quote

“I'm going to be biased when I give you reasons. You will evaluate them quite objectively... that's what makes the whole thing work is this kind of back and forth between the production of reasons, which is biased and the evaluation of other people's reasons, which is much more objective”

Source

233 | Hugo Mercier on Reasoning and Skepticism— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...