causal

Neutral probability needed to avoid begging the question

When adjudicating between two competing scientific theories—especially two competing theories of probability—you cannot use the probability notion that one theory endorses and the other rejects, because that begs the question against the other theory; therefore you need a neutral, impartial, epistemic notion of probability (the Bayesian approach) to assess which theory the evidence favors.

causalpending

Speaker

Branden Fitelson

Evidence Quote

“you need some other notion of probability, something neutral like a judge is impartial. So you need some impartial notion of probability.”

Source

315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...