factual

Common knowledge of posteriors needs shared evidence

Aumann's Agreement Theorem requires common knowledge of each other's posteriors, but achieving genuine common knowledge in practice is very hard because the same posterior can result from very different underlying evidence (overlapping observations, independent observations, or much larger samples); distinguishing these cases generally requires sharing the actual evidence, so the conversational 'dances' that approximate agreement rarely shortcut the need to exchange evidence.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“rational people with common priors didn't need to share evidence to reach agreement, they just needed "common knowledge of each other's posteriors"”

Source

AMA | October 2025— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...