normative
Carroll's Least-Presumptuous Bullet to Bite
Carroll proposes that the least presumptuous response to anthropic puzzles is to judge cosmological theories only by whether they predict that observers exactly like oneself should arise—not by assuming such observers are typical—and to accept that when two large universes both almost certainly contain an observer just like you, you cannot use your existence to discriminate between them.
normativepending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“in those cases where both universes are big enough that even though the averages are different there... It is very likely that an observer just like me exists in both of them. I cannot judge between them. That's what I... I would actually accept that conclusion. That seems to be the least presumptuous thing I can do.”
Source
111 | Nick Bostrom on Anthropic Selection and Living in a Simulation— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:21:43 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...