factual
Value May Be Bounded With Diminishing Returns
Intuitions suggest the total value of good lives may be bounded with diminishing returns—people reluctant to gamble a flourishing 100-trillion-person utopia for a 50% chance of three such utopias versus extinction—but if value is bounded then present decisions absurdly depend on how many good or bad lives existed in the past or elsewhere in the universe, so every view of aggregation faces a paradox.
factualpending
Speaker
William MacAskillEvidence Quote
“take this flourishing Utopian civilization, have it three times over, maybe that's 10% better or something, 'cause you're very close to this upper bound of value. However, there are really bad problems for that view too”
Source
207 | William MacAskill on Maximizing Good in the Present and Future— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:14:05 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...