definition

Two-dimensional theory of argument strength

Argument strength is irreducibly two-dimensional, given by an ordered pair: the conditional probability of the conclusion given the premise (which should exceed one-half) and the Bayes factor measuring the evidence's relevance/confirmation; no single number can totally order all arguments, because evidence that is irrelevant—even if the conclusion is probable given it—is not a reason to believe the conclusion.

definitionpending

Speaker

Branden Fitelson

Evidence Quote

“One of the real deepest mistakes that was made in the history of Inductive logic was that they thought there'd be a single measure on which you could totally order all the arguments in terms of their strength.”

Source

315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...