factual
Moral philosophy is a game of edge cases vs intuitions
Academic moral philosophy functions as a game in which a theory is advanced and critics find edge cases that violate moral intuitions; the theorist must then either bite the bullet or keep expanding their definitions until the theory becomes a tautology matching pre-existing intuitions—an emptiness Hoel sees at the heart of the field.
factualpending
Speaker
Eric HoelEvidence Quote
“you have to to bite the bullet now maybe there's some sort of perfect point on the spectrum where it's sort of convincing enough and you're and you're biting the bullet but it's always in sort of interesting ways that you can sort of be convinced of after the fact”
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:53:51 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...