The Smithian ideal is not about big versus small states per se but about a state big enough to provide necessary public order and public goods while small in the things that interfere with anonymous exchange; the enduring paradox is that any state strong enough to do the good things is strong enough to do bad things, so the real question is how many bad things one tolerates to obtain the good.

normativepending

Speaker

John Nye

Evidence Quote

“the puzzle we can parrot or out of the paradox we have is that any state strong enough to ride first is strong enough to do bad things in the second and so there's always been a big debate as to how many bad things you're willing to tolerate in order to get more of the good things”

Source

John Nye on the Great Depression, Political Economy, and the Evolution of the State 09/14/2009— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:01:02 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...