normative

Biosphere thought experiment over the repugnant conclusion

Gray poses a thought experiment distinct from Parfit's repugnant conclusion: choosing between a world of 100 billion humans all living very worthwhile lives but with no other species, versus a world with a much smaller human population alongside a thriving biosphere; he, not being a utilitarian, would prefer the second, echoing Mill's view that a world without 'flowery wastes' would be barely worth living in.

normativepending

Speaker

John Gray

Evidence Quote

“the second world, the world in which there are fewer human beings living well, but ... without what he called flowery wastes ... the world would be barren and, he thought, almost not worth living in, and I share that view.”

Source

John Gray— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:28:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...