normative

Honesty about pony meat beats covert castration

Maintaining a wild Exmoor pony herd requires culling because there is no viable market otherwise, and castrating males to limit numbers is distressing and destroys herd dynamism (no play-fighting colts, no foals, risk of laminitis); it is more humane and honest to cull and sell conservation-grade pony meat—which is as good as beef—than to secretly transport live ponies to France or castrate them and pretend there is no problem.

normativepending

Speaker

Isabella Tree

Evidence Quote

“if you cull them then I think it--you also need to eat the meat, because horse meat is just as good as beef, and we should just be honest about it, rather than trying to hide it away.”

Source

Isabella Tree on Wilding— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:31:17 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...