factual

Same Experience Across Substrates Is Behavioral Sameness

On Clark's functionalist illusionism, two systems with very different architectures (wetware and silicon) instantiate the same experience—the same perfect blue—not by sharing a subjective extra fact but by performing the same way when asked to sort, group, match, and describe; there is no further always-missing instantaneous fact of sameness because experience is constituted by its evolution over time, including subsequent comparison and report.

factualpending

Speaker

Andy Clark

Evidence Quote

“it's the evolution over time that counts and that means that experiments that involve things like stopping the system and asking it to compare or report a fair game”

Source

322 - Predicting Reality— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:16:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...