factual

Concrete Mystical Experiences Demand Explanation

The supernatural experiences that are more persuasive are those that are not just law-of-large-numbers events but have concrete reality—intensity, physical correlates like healing, or striking specificity—such as the Michael Shermer broken radio that played appropriate music only during his wedding and never worked again, which requires some explanation beyond coincidence.

factualpending

Speaker

Ross Douthat

Evidence Quote

“it's a good case study of the kind of thing... that happens in the world that you need some explanation besides just coincidence and the law of large numbers to explain”

Source

Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:12 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...