The true anomaly is not that intellectuals favor an interventionist state but that anyone favors a relatively non-interventionist state built on anonymous exchange; since most people throughout history have opposed a liberal state, the real puzzle is why Smithian liberalism ever gained any influence at all—and even 'liberal Britain' was far less liberal than its propagandists made it appear.

factualpending

Speaker

John Nye

Evidence Quote

“the rise of intellectuals or anyone interested in promoting a non-interventionist state is the true... anomaly because the... state which believes in anonymous exchange is so rare itself so the real issue is why we have Smith having any influence whatsoever”

Source

John Nye on the Great Depression, Political Economy, and the Evolution of the State 09/14/2009— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:01:02 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...