normative
Quine's attack warrants re-examination
Bright argues that Quine's attack on analyticity, launched in the 1950s, relied on the claim that certain notions (synonymy, necessary equivalence) couldn't be made sense of, but later developments—particularly modal logic and possible-worlds machinery—now give tools to make sense of those notions, so the philosophical lore that the distinction was refuted warrants re-examination.
normativepending
Speaker
Liam Kofi BrightEvidence Quote
“I think it was sensible in light of the state of theoretical development at the time, but I don't think it really bears out. And so it sort of entered philosophical lore that this was refuted, but I think it was sort of, that decision warrants re-examination in light of later developments.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:43 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...