Peirce rejects the Cartesian criterion of clarity and distinctness (whatever I am clearly convinced of is true) because conviction is subjective and variable; clarity and distinctness are criteria of meaningfulness rather than truth.

factualpending

Speaker

Unknown Lecturer

Evidence Quote

“the same formalism appears in the Cartesian criterion which amounts to this whatever I'm clearly convinced of it's true well obviously the quest becomes moot because if everybody was convinced...clarity and distinctness of criteria of meaningfulness rather than truth to say it's clear and distinct means oh I see what you mean rather than necessarily it's true”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 64 American Pragmatism— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:07:12 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...