normative

Ordered-signatory peer review allocates credit better

Replacing the binary author-versus-referee structure of journals with an ordered list of signatories—authors first, then editor, then referees—would be a more incentive-compatible way to elicit quality referee reports and allocate credit in proportion to contribution, potentially enhanced with quadratic voting and individualized, respect-weighted citation views.

normativepending

Speaker

Glen Weyl

Evidence Quote

“I think this would be a much more incentive-compatible way to get good-quality referee reports and to actually allocate credit in proportion to what people have contributed to making an article work, as compared to the current system, where there’s a very binary division between the authors who get credit and everybody else who gets very little.”

Source

Glen Weyl— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:24:00 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...